$640,000

$3,436 est/mo Sourced by Back At You

26 Garfield Avenue,East Islip, NY 11730

East Islip, NY 11730

Images Tour Map

Single-story residence featuring light gray shingle siding

Expansive verdant lawn featuring mature shade trees, a shingled house with an exterior deck, and an additional storage shed

Hardwood flooring throughout, recessed ceiling lighting, baseboard heating, a single window, and a diagonal wood-paneled accent wall with an open doorway

Living area featuring wood-finish flooring, white walls, and recessed lighting

Kitchen featuring light gray cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and wood-finish flooring

Contemporary kitchen featuring light gray cabinetry, granite countertops, and stainless steel appliances including an over-the-range microwave and a gas range

Room featuring wood-finish flooring, a white ceiling fan with integrated lighting, a single window with blinds, and a baseboard heating unit

Room featuring wood-finish flooring, white walls, a ceiling fan, and sliding mirrored closet doors

Glass-enclosed shower with a built-in bench and dual showerheads

Room featuring wood-finish flooring, white crown molding, and baseboards

Full Basement -Length of House22'.83" X 35'.3"Washer and Dryer

Expansive wood deck with a full railing system24' X 16'

Exterior photo of outside detached secondary building

Lawn with mature trees and a secondary building featuring wood shingle siding and white-framed French doors

3 Framed Rooms

Framing and rough plumbing

Floorplan

Description

Opportunity Knocks at 26 Garfield Ave! Historic Charm + Massive Potential Discover this charming two-bedroom, one-bath 1920's Vintage cottage situated on a beautiful .34 lot in a highly sought-after East Islip neighborhood. Perfect for first-time homebuyers, downsizers, investors or anyone looking to create their dream space. Property Highlights: Historic Charm: A cozy ranch layout with a warm, inviting vibe, surrounded by unique homes. Tastefully updated kitchen with new appliances, full bath, wood floors throughout, The Ultimate Bonus Space: A detached garage partially finished with cedar siding, fully framed, with windows, French, sliding glass doors, windows, skylight, and rough plumbing already in place. Perfect for a home office, art studio, or outside pool house. Full Basement: Vintage Staircase - Caution when navigating - Sliding Glass Doors Off Back of House leading to Oversize Wood Decking Location, Location: Situated in the renowned East Islip School District, Close to Fire Island Ferries and Islip Town Beach Parks, LIRR commute to NYC, Shopping, Famous Restaurants, this community has it all! Whether you want to move right in and update over time or expand the footprint to create something spectacular, the possibilities are truly endless. Bring your vision and make this gem your own!

Details

MLS #	900208
Listing Type	For Sale
Style	House
Sub-Type	Resale
Status	Active
Year	1920
Days On Site	85
Listing Provided By	Howard Hanna Coach \| Diane M. Milliard

Features

Bed(s)	2
Bath(s)	1 Total
SQ Feet	864
Garage	1
Basement	Y
Story(s)	1
Acreage	0.34

Interior

Cooling	Wall/Window Unit(s)
Heating	Baseboard
Interior Features	First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Ceiling Fan(s), Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Granite Counters, Natural Woodwork, Storage
Appliances	Convection Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Stainless Steel Appliance(s)

Exterior

Exterior Features	Mailbox
Construction Materials	Cedar
Foundation Details	Block
Lot Features	Level

Parking

Garage Yes / No	Yes
Parking Features	Driveway

Utilities

Utilities	Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected, Sewer Connected, Trash Collection Public, Water Connected
Sewer	Public Sewer

Taxes

Tax Year	2025
Tax Assessed Value	29250
Tax Annual Amount	9165.86

Area Information

State	NY
County	Suffolk County
City	East Islip
Zip Code	11730
School District	East Islip High School
Elementary School	Connetquot Elementary School
High School	East Islip High School
Listing VS Median (in 11730)
Price: $640,000 low \| high Med: $699,999 40.62515625% of Average sqft: 864 low \| high Med: 3,116 100% of Average $ / sqft: $741 low \| high Med: $225 100% of Average On site: 85 low \| high Med: 120 70.833333333333% of Average

Sourced by Back At You

Market Activity 11730

Date	Sales	Avg $ Per SqFt	Min Sale Price	Max Sale Price	Med Sale Price
Date: Jun 2026	Sales: 2	Avg $ Per SqFt: $366.23	Min Sale Price: $600,000	Max Sale Price: $800,000	Med Sale Price: $700,000
Date: May 2026	Sales: 9	Avg $ Per SqFt: $450.71	Min Sale Price: $615,000	Max Sale Price: $995,000	Med Sale Price: $780,000
Date: Apr 2026	Sales: 11	Avg $ Per SqFt: $482.13	Min Sale Price: $500,000	Max Sale Price: $1,280,000	Med Sale Price: $800,000
Date: Mar 2026	Sales: 8	Avg $ Per SqFt: $506.49	Min Sale Price: $495,000	Max Sale Price: $850,000	Med Sale Price: $650,000
Date: Feb 2026	Sales: 5	Avg $ Per SqFt: $454.44	Min Sale Price: $685,000	Max Sale Price: $1,160,000	Med Sale Price: $750,000
Date: Jan 2026	Sales: 3	Avg $ Per SqFt: $408.9	Min Sale Price: $310,000	Max Sale Price: $995,000	Med Sale Price: $831,000
Date: Dec 2025	Sales: 12	Avg $ Per SqFt: $384	Min Sale Price: $2,170	Max Sale Price: $990,000	Med Sale Price: $767,500
Date: Nov 2025	Sales: 9	Avg $ Per SqFt: $436.45	Min Sale Price: $275,000	Max Sale Price: $2,050,000	Med Sale Price: $915,000
Date: Oct 2025	Sales: 8	Avg $ Per SqFt: $462.41	Min Sale Price: $545,000	Max Sale Price: $1,575,000	Med Sale Price: $691,500
Date: Sep 2025	Sales: 3	Avg $ Per SqFt: $399.45	Min Sale Price: $975,000	Max Sale Price: $1,200,000	Med Sale Price: $990,000
Date: Aug 2025	Sales: 2	Avg $ Per SqFt: $356.41	Min Sale Price: $635,000	Max Sale Price: $645,000	Med Sale Price: $640,000

Sourced by Back At You

Jun 2026
Sales:	2
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$366.23
Min Sale Price:	$600,000
Max Sale Price:	$800,000
Med Sale Price:	$700,000
May 2026
Sales:	9
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$450.71
Min Sale Price:	$615,000
Max Sale Price:	$995,000
Med Sale Price:	$780,000
Apr 2026
Sales:	11
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$482.13
Min Sale Price:	$500,000
Max Sale Price:	$1,280,000
Med Sale Price:	$800,000
Mar 2026
Sales:	8
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$506.49
Min Sale Price:	$495,000
Max Sale Price:	$850,000
Med Sale Price:	$650,000
Feb 2026
Sales:	5
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$454.44
Min Sale Price:	$685,000
Max Sale Price:	$1,160,000
Med Sale Price:	$750,000
Jan 2026
Sales:	3
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$408.9
Min Sale Price:	$310,000
Max Sale Price:	$995,000
Med Sale Price:	$831,000
Dec 2025
Sales:	12
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$384
Min Sale Price:	$2,170
Max Sale Price:	$990,000
Med Sale Price:	$767,500
Nov 2025
Sales:	9
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$436.45
Min Sale Price:	$275,000
Max Sale Price:	$2,050,000
Med Sale Price:	$915,000
Oct 2025
Sales:	8
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$462.41
Min Sale Price:	$545,000
Max Sale Price:	$1,575,000
Med Sale Price:	$691,500
Sep 2025
Sales:	3
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$399.45
Min Sale Price:	$975,000
Max Sale Price:	$1,200,000
Med Sale Price:	$990,000
Aug 2025
Sales:	2
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$356.41
Min Sale Price:	$635,000
Max Sale Price:	$645,000
Med Sale Price:	$640,000

Request a showing

Contact

Learn More About This Property

Tammy Jo Odell

John J Lease REALTORS

ABR, CBR, SFR (845) 541-8014 tammyjoodell@gmail.com

State	NY
County	Suffolk County
City	East Islip
Zip Code	11730
School District	East Islip High School
Elementary School	Connetquot Elementary School
High School	East Islip High School
Listing VS Median (in 11730)
Price: $640,000 low \| high Med: $699,999 40.62515625% of Average sqft: 864 low \| high Med: 3,116 100% of Average $ / sqft: $741 low \| high Med: $225 100% of Average On site: 85 low \| high Med: 120 70.833333333333% of Average

Sourced by Back At You

Listing Updated: August 16, 2026 at 7:18:52 PM PDT

26 Garfield Avenue,East Islip, NY 11730

East Islip, NY 11730

Description

Details

Features

Interior

Exterior

Parking

Utilities

Taxes

Area Information

Market Activity 11730

Request a showing

Request a showing

Contact

Additional Information

Showing Information

Submit Form

Contact

Learn More About This Property

Tammy Jo Odell

John J Lease REALTORS

Contact

Additional Information

Submit Form

Attachments

Loading

Tammy Odell - John J Lease Realtors

26 Garfield Avenue,East Islip, NY 11730

East Islip, NY 11730

Share:

Description

Details

Features

Interior

Exterior

Parking

Utilities

Taxes

Area Information

Market Activity 11730

Request a showing

Request a showing

Contact

Additional Information

Showing Information

Submit Form

Contact

Learn More About This Property

Tammy Jo Odell

John J Lease REALTORS

Contact

Additional Information

Submit Form

Attachments

Loading

Tammy Odell - John J Lease Realtors